Independent cost benchmarks · United States

Know what a home project costs before the contractor arrives.

Cost guides publish ranges. Homeowners receive quotes. HomeCostBench puts the two side by side: we collect the quotes people actually post, normalize them to cost per square foot by scope, and compare them with the published numbers. Every figure is dated and linked to its source, and every dataset is downloadable.

Read the first benchmark: attic insulation cost

Cost benchmarks

8 published · more in research
Insulation · Nov 8, 2026

Attic insulation cost 2026: 19 real quotes vs. the guides

Guides say $1,700–$2,700. Posted quotes had a median of $5,025. Cost per square foot by scope, a quote checker and the open dataset.

Roofing · Nov 19, 2026

Roof replacement cost 2026: 44 real quotes vs. the guides

Guides say $9,600 on average. Posted quotes had a median of $22,900, or $727 per roofing square for asphalt. Cost by scope, a quote checker and the open dataset.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

HVAC replacement cost 2026: 146 real quotes, priced per ton

One manufacturer guide gives $5,000–$28,000. Posted quotes had a median of $13,000 per system, or $5,072 per ton for AC plus furnace. Cost by system type and size, a quote checker and the open dataset.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

Water heater replacement cost 2026: 66 real prices vs. the guides

Angi reports an average of $1,349. Posted prices for a standard tank had a median of $3,262, and tankless quotes $8,000. Prices by heater type and size, a quote checker and the open dataset.

Windows · Nov 19, 2026

Window replacement cost 2026: 54 real quotes per window

Guides say $517 to $800 per window. Posted quotes had a median of $1,778, and $3,454 from Renewal by Andersen, Pella and Marvin. Cost by brand, a quote checker and the open dataset.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

Mini split installation cost 2026: 69 real quotes per zone

Guides say $2,000 to $6,000 for one zone. Posted quotes had a median of $8,000, and $5,902 per zone for larger systems. Cost by zones and brand, a quote checker and the open dataset.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

Water softener installation cost 2026: 59 real quotes

Guides say $1,500 on average. Posted quotes for an installed system had a median of $4,000: $5,985 from dealer brands and $3,375 from local installers. A quote checker and the open dataset.

Garage · Nov 19, 2026

Garage door replacement cost 2026: 44 real quotes

Guides say $754 to $1,707. Posted quotes had a median of $2,900 per door installed, and spring repairs a median of $1,000 against a published $250. A quote checker and the open dataset.

Notes from the data

Short answers to one question
Roofing · Nov 19, 2026

Is $30,000 too much for a roof?

Typical for about 40 squares of asphalt shingles, high for 30 or fewer. Where it lands against 44 real quotes.

Roofing · Nov 19, 2026

Metal roof vs. shingles cost: same-house quotes

Ten homeowners posted both quotes for one house. Exposed-fastener metal ran about the same as shingles; standing seam about double.

Roofing · Nov 19, 2026

Roof decking replacement cost per sheet

Posted quotes charged $50 to $95 per extra sheet, with 3 to 10 sheets included. Full re-decks ran $8,000 to $16,000.

Insulation · Nov 19, 2026

Attic insulation removal cost

Guides say $1 to $3 per sq ft. In four same-attic quote pairs, removal added $1,000 to $6,000.

Insulation · Nov 19, 2026

Blown-in attic insulation cost

Six posted quotes ran $1.43 to $3.71 per sq ft, median $2.42. What R49 vs. R60 adds, and why small attics cost more.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

Heat pump vs. AC cost in same-home quotes

In seven quote pairs the heat pump version cost $1,500 to $5,120 more, median $3,200. Rebates cut the gap about in half.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

Is $20,000 too much for a new HVAC system?

Only 18 of 137 posted quotes were that high. Most were 3.5 tons or larger, or included ducts or zoning.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

AC unit cost installed by size

3-ton quotes ran $7,900 to $13,000 and 4-ton quotes $11,000 to $15,500, a median of $3,312 per ton for AC alone.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

Tankless water heater installation cost

Eight posted quotes ran $6,600 to $12,000, median $8,000. The gas line moved one quote by $4,000.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

Is $3,000 too much for a water heater?

30 of 48 posted prices were $3,000 or more. After a second quote, homeowners paid $1,750 to $2,500.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

50-gallon water heater cost installed

21 posted prices ran $2,150 to $4,800, median $2,800. Power-vent tanks were quoted $3,900 to $7,100.

Windows · Nov 19, 2026

Renewal by Andersen cost per window

Three posted quotes came to $3,050, $4,500 and $5,111 per window. Door prices and what the company says about discounts.

Windows · Nov 19, 2026

Pella window cost installed

Posted quotes came to $2,083, $3,429 and $3,556 per window, with one at about $7,000.

Windows · Nov 19, 2026

Vinyl window replacement cost

Ten posted quotes ran $500 to $2,417 per window installed, median $1,146.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

Mitsubishi mini split cost installed

One zone: $4,000 to $25,000, median $9,800, against $5,888 for other brands.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

Mini split for a garage

Ten posted quotes ran $3,000 to $9,800 installed, median $5,892.

HVAC · Nov 19, 2026

Whole-house mini split cost

29 quotes for four to seven zones ran $12,325 to $53,000, median $25,303.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

Culligan water softener cost

Three posted quotes were $2,950, $4,400 and $6,500 to buy; rentals $60 to $70 a month.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

Kinetico water softener cost

Four posted quotes ran $2,900 to $5,985 installed, and $7,500 with whole-house filtration.

Plumbing · Nov 19, 2026

Plumber cost to install a water softener

Twelve posted quotes ran $375 to $7,800, median $1,200. What a missing loop adds.

Garage · Nov 19, 2026

Garage door spring replacement cost

Nine posted prices ran $395 to $3,000, median $1,000. Springs alone: $395 to $470.

Garage · Nov 19, 2026

Garage door opener installation cost

Labor only was quoted at $230 to $500; with the opener supplied, $550 to $2,000.

Garage · Nov 19, 2026

Double garage door cost

Six posted quotes ran $1,850 to $7,300 installed: three at $3,000 or less, three at $5,680 or more.

How a benchmark is built

Each benchmark starts with public homeowner reports that state a price, a scope and, where possible, a size. We code the scope, compute cost per square foot, and set the results against every major cost guide with its publication date. Small samples are shown with their size, outliers are kept and labeled, and the raw rows are published as CSV. Read the full methodology.